Darrick Forrest
06.09.2019
English
Teacher
Inquiry-based Research Paper
Concussion Prevention Research in Football
For the last decade, football has competed as the leading cause for concussions in sports. The continuous clashing of helmets and thrusting hackling motions, have been known to result in major trauma to the external body eventually ending in even more damage to the internal body (ie. many pivotal brain regions). Many are unaware of the long term effect that this routine movement can cause on the brain, however researchers are joining in the efforts to find a complete prevention .
Question: Athletes all over the world are questioning if the prevention of concussions are realistic, while others are grounded in their truth that concussions are inevitable. In football it is difficult to avoid incidents such as this being that the behavior is casual in the field of play.
Mayo Clinic describes concussions as a “traumatic brain injury that affects your brain function.” The effects are typically temporary, however, may include symptoms such as: headaches, difficulty concentrating, memory loss as well as off centered equilibrium and coordination. Webmd describes concussions as one of the most common and least serious type of traumatic brain injuries. Derived from the latin work concuture meaning to shake violently. In football this is common form of interaction.
According to “PT in Motion News” from 2015, Concussion Rates among NCAA sports, football is said to be on top in regards to sports related concussions (src), both in practicing and competing. The article goes on to say that the top 10 sports in terms of src rates were football in third place at a 6.71 rating, followed by women’s soccer. It is described that player to player contact sports such as football and women’s soccer will naturally result in src, for this reason it is the leading cause. Which includes but is not limited to: floor balls, surface contact during takedown,and tackling.
Though football is among the leading sports for SRC, Webmd explains that SRC are indeed on the rise in school age children. Supported by 2010 studies, the number of young children treated in Emergency Rooms for concussions has
doubled in the last decade. While it is said that concussion rates are higher in high school age athletes, researchers say that the rate among younger athletes are not only on the rise but significant to watch for. In supervising young athletes this is imperative to watch for, being that the progression of the athlete will not reach its full maturation in regards to decreased or stunted cognitive development . Lack of this developmental function will make it difficult for athletes to peak.
Across the nation, the most common concussions statistics in football are as followed: Roughly half a million ER visits for concussions occurred among 8- to 19-year-olds between 2001 and 2005; as well as, About half were sports-related, and 40% of sports-related concussions involved children between the ages of 8 and 13. It is imperative that both parents and coaches are attentive to the behavior in which their child portrays. Often times, concussions go undetected which stunts the healing process for your neurological development. Signs, although are not always easy to detect are as follows: nausea,confusion, or feeling dazed,clumsiness and slurred speech, blurred vision,sensitivity to light and noise, behavior or personality changes,memory loss and concentration difficulties.
Though a consistent prevention has not yet been discovered there are several suggested precautions to take when falling under the category of the previously
listed symptoms. Primarily it is advised to simply take a break. Often times athletes are trained to push through all adversity,however, it is very important to listen to your body and give yourself time to reset. It is also important to guard against repeat concussions. Concussions are unlike many sports related injuries. It is often times difficult to gage whether or not you are able to “tough it out” and work through the pain, however, the cumulative effects on the brain will increase consequences. Which include brain swelling, permanent brain damage, long term disabilities, or even death. It is also advised to refrain from normal activities if you still have symptoms 24 to 72 hours post trauma.
A few suggested methods for prevention, granting it may or may not be completely successful. Wearing protective equipment; and withstaining from altercations as they are reported most for traumatic head injuries. Nonetheless, the advised football safety tips are
National College Athletic Association (NCAA) magazine gives an overview of concussions in regards to safety processions. Although WedMd suggested a few safety precautions and that being of wearing head protection, NCAA warns us that athletes may suffer a concussion even after wearing a helmet. Nonetheless, the National College Association provides a list of prevention tips as well as the playing rules and safety.
“1916: First NCAA Football Rules Code developed and published. 1939: All players required to wear helmets. 1964: No player may deliberately and maliciously use his helmet or head to butt or ram an opponent. 1973: All players required to wear mouth protectors. 1975: Published Heat Illness Prevention Guideline. 1976: Spearing redefined as “the deliberate use of the helmet in an attempt to punish the opponent.” 1994: Published Concussion Guideline. 1996: If the ball carrier’s helmet comes off, the play is blown dead immediately. 2002: A “defenseless player” is defined for added protection of players. 2003: Mandated new preseason training schedule. Mandated preparticipation medical examinations. 2006: Eye shields must be completely clear to allow for quick medical diagnoses of student-athletes. 2008: The horse-collar tackle is illegal; players protected from a chop-block; and focus on eliminating hits on defenseless players and blows to the head. 2010: Mandated Concussion Management Plan. 2010: Mandated that any injured player be removed from play and cleared by medical personnel before returning to play. Limited blocking schemed on kick plays to not more than two players shoulder to shoulder.”